|
I
started with a Meade LPI back in 2001 when I had the 8" LX90 (and I
still have the LPI though I don't use it anymore) I quickly moved
to a 'proper' camera an purchased a Starlight Xpress MX516. The
FOV was tiny and not very productive so I upgraded to an MX716 (ST-7
sized). An SBIG ST-8 'dropped' into my lap in 2005 when I won my
first Gene Shoemaker NEO grant, and this became the observatories
mainstay for many years. Over the ensuing years I bought and sold
a second MX716 and an SBIG ST-9.
In
2011, with the money from another Gene Shoemaker Grant, I purchased an
SBIG STL1001e. Now I am after another small, sensitive CCD with
small pixels to use with the Spectrograph, most likely an Atik 314L+.
It seems to be most suited to the specifics of the L200 and considerably
smaller (in physical size and more importantly weight) to the ST-8.
SBIG
STL1001E with integrated Filterwheel
A large format, professional grade CCD
camera from SBIG. The STL1001e has a 1024x1024, 24micron CCD chip
with a peak QE of a little over 70%. This configuration allows me
to operate the camera at near f/10 on the 14" SCT (with the Meade
Microfocuser attached the result is actually f/9.4) resulting in a 25.4
arcmin square field at 1.48 arcsec/pixel resolution. First light
for this camera was 23 April 2011. Although the Camera has an integrated
filter wheel, 2" UBVRI filters are very expensive so none are fitted as
yet. However, par focal Custom Scientific V, R and C filters are
on order. Mind you there appears to be a serious construction flaw
in this camera given the filterwheel circuit board joint 'popped' off
the circuit board when the camera face plate was removed. This
isn't an isolated incident either (I know one owner who has had this
happen 3 times and a lot of other users came out of the woodwork when I
posted the issue on the SBIG user forum) but SBIG quickly came to the
party and is sending a replacement part.
I did some testing on the old part and the design is sound, as long as
the solder joints are robust so the issue seems to be with the quality
of construction rather than the design.
SBIG
ST-8E with CFW8 Filterwheel
Although a Parallel interface camera, the ST-8E has been
the mainstay of the HHO for more than 5 years. To cater for
automation, the camera and CFW8 filter wheel were fitted with a Meade
F/3.3 Focal Reducer resulting in an f/4 imaging system. The
resulting field curvature was a drawback but since it is a parallel
camera, full frame image downloads took too long (59 seconds) so sub
frame imaging was introduced to combat the vignetting and the download
times. As a result, reasonable images were obtained with only an
average 20 second delay at 1148 x 768 px. The only other issue was
that during image download, the camera took over all the computers CPU
cycles and as a result accuracy of system time was grossly affected (I
found instances where the system clock was off by 200+ seconds at the
end of a nights run - even with internet time synching operating.
This, and the relatively slow image download times made the camera
useless for NEOCP followup work.
For photometry, CBVRI filters were installed in the
CFW8 filter wheel (C being a par focal Clear filter). This Camera
was retired from main use on 22 April 2011 and retasked to the L200
Spectroscope.
SX
MX716
If Starlight Xpress had got the interface and driver
software right for this camera off the bat I would not have had so many
issues and would likely have stuck with the company. As it was
they used a non standard interface and drivers that no-one (except SX
and AstroArt) supported. In 2005, almost a full 5 years into the
SX camera production, suitable drivers were written (by a SX customer
mind you) and support for the Cameras became more widespread. Mind
you the Star2000 guider interface has become a mainstay for users who
wanted autoguiding but no dedicated ST-4 guider port on their mounts.
Now drivers and software compatibility aside, the SX range of cameras
that I have used have been very good at what they do and if they
supported mechanical shutters and regulated/setable cooling then I would
go back to them in a heartbeat.
|